New York Dearest
The guide, $35
A restaurant · Theater District · on 2 of my lists

Carmine's.

Only if, says Antonina. It is directly across from the St. James and steps from the Majestic and Broadhurst.

Antonina Pattiz
Antonina PattizI went myself · from my Best places to eat before a Broadway matinee
What this page is

Everything I’ve written about Carmine's on New York Dearest, in one place. It’s on 2 of my lists, from Best kid-friendly restaurants in New York to Best places to eat before a Broadway matinee, and each one says something the others don’t. Below you’ll find what I order and what to know, in my own words from those lists, every list it’s on with what I wrote there, and where it is and what’s near.

  1. Best kid-friendly restaurants in New YorkWorth it
  2. Best places to eat before a Broadway matineeOnly if

Before you go, in my words

Quoted from my own lists
What I order

Get there when they open, around 11 on Saturdays, order two or three platters for the table, and let the family bicker over the last of the linguine while somebody flags the check.

From Best places to eat before a Broadway matinee
Good to know

You could genuinely finish your last bite of chicken parm, walk out the door, and be in your seat in the time it takes to find your row.

From Best places to eat before a Broadway matinee
Only if, says Antonina. Been? Say if you agree.

Where it appears on New York Dearest

2 of my lists, the fullest first
What I wrote thereFold it away

For over 30 years, Carmine’s has been one of the most iconic family restaurants in New York City. The restaurant serves all the typical Italian fared food, from pasta to some of the best tiramisu. But what sets them apart is the portion sizes.

The kid-friendly NYC restaurant has been welcoming visitors and locals alike since 1990. It’s rare to find the place empty. I brought my sisters here on their first trip to the Big Apple and they still reminisce of the meal often, it was that memorable to them!

Read it on the list
  • Address200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
  • From my guide, published November 2023.

It is directly across from the St. James and steps from the Majestic and Broadhurst.

What I wrote thereFold it away

Carmine’s is the loud, giant, family-style Italian right in the belly of West 44th, and for a group it is unbeatable for one reason. It is directly across from the St. James and steps from the Majestic and Broadhurst. You could genuinely finish your last bite of chicken parm, walk out the door, and be in your seat in the time it takes to find your row.

Portions are enormous and meant for sharing, so this is a place for four or more, not a solo lunch. Get there when they open, around 11 on Saturdays, order two or three platters for the table, and let the family bicker over the last of the linguine while somebody flags the check. Is it a locals-only secret? Absolutely not. But when you are wrangling six people and a 2 o’clock curtain across the street, “one minute away” beats “authentic” every single time.

On The Best of New York

I put Carmine's on my best list.

Missing something?

A closure, a price that moved, a better one next door.

Tell me and the desk checks it before anything changes here. When I answer, it lands on this page and in your inbox.

Tell me

The letter

One email a week when New York changes. A place closes, a date lands, I finally try somewhere. Written by me, not a robot.

One a week at most. Unsubscribe in one click.