New York Dearest
The guide, $35

Eat · Desserts · 2026

The best black and white cookies in New York.

Every one from my own visits, updated September 2026. 6 places.

Originating from Eastern European Jewish immigrants, the black and white cookie has risen from humble beginnings to become a beloved staple in New York City’s bakeries. Finding great black and white cookies. With its distinctive yin-yang appearance and perfect balance of vanilla and chocolate flavors, this iconic treat symbolizes the city’s cultural diversity and is a true representation of the city’s melting pot.

Antonina PattizI went to every one · how I decide
  1. Bread's BakeryBakery · Upper East SideBut trust me when I tell you the trek is worth the treat.
  2. Empire CakeBakery · ChelseaUnlike other black and white cookies in New York City that only ice the top, the chocolate dip makes this one of the sweetest black and white cookies in New York City.
  3. OrwashersBakery · Upper East Side & Upper West SideThe frosting perfectly complements the cookie’s soft texture, offering a treat that melts in your mouth.
  4. Russ & DaughtersBakery · Lower East SideBreaking it in half reveals a satisfying snap, creating the ideal complement to their incredible bagels.
  5. William GreenbergBakery · Upper East Side & Upper West SideKnown as the quintessential and most iconic in NYC, these cookies offer a burst of originality.
  6. Zabar'sMarket · Upper West SideNot too big and not too sweet, the cookie at Zabar’s is expertly balanced.

Best black and white cookies in New York, 2026

The seal

Every place on this list can show it. It links back here, so a reader sees the whole list and how it was made. No fee.

Is one of these yours?

The full guide, with the ones that didn't make it and why: 5+ Flavorful Black and White Cookies in New York City.