New York Dearest
The guide, $35

Eat · Iconic and old New York · 2026

The oldest restaurants in New York.

A list, not a ranking, from my own visits, updated September 2026. 10 places.

New York City has one of the most exciting food scenes in the world. Here’s my honest take on oldest restaurants in New York City. the tips, the tricks, and what to skip entirely. Every year, the city welcomes hungry visitors with open arms, offering an array of cuisines that span the gamut. However, some folks find themselves curious about the oldest restaurants in NYC, if you’re in the same boat then I’m here to help.

It’s wild to think that some of New York City’s oldest restaurants predate iconic landmarks like Central Park and the Statue of Liberty, but it’s true. Remarkably, these time-honored eateries continue to serve customers to this day.

Antonina PattizI went to every one · how I decide
  1. Fraunces TavernRestaurant · Financial DistrictNeedless to say, enjoying a pint (or cocktail) at Fraunces Tavern is one of the best things to do in the Financial District, if not for the history alone.
  2. Ear InnBar · Hudson SquareThe bar's historic atmosphere, marked by a distinctive neon sign and maritime artifacts, has been preserved over the years.
  3. Neir's TavernBar · WoodhavenToday, it remains a cherished neighborhood bar with a storied past few can resist.
  4. Delmonico'sRestaurant · Financial DistrictHeavy hitters include tender Rib eyes, fresh oysters and luxurious caviar.
  5. Pete's TavernRestaurant · Gramercy ParkI've been here in every season. My favorite? Fall, when the light hits just right.
  6. Landmark TavernRestaurant · Midtown WestThis one of those New York moments that makes you fall in love with the city all over again.
  7. Old Homestead SteakhouseRestaurant · Chelsea
  8. P.J. Clarke'sRestaurant · Midtown EastDeserving of the accolades inherent to the oldest restaurants in New York City, this spot is a favorite among locals for burgers to this day.
  9. Keens SteakhouseRestaurant · MidtownThis one of those places that makes you fall for New York City all over again.
  10. Katz's DelicatessenRestaurant · Lower East SideRenowned for traditional Jewish fare, this kosher-style deli is best known for world-famous mile-high pastrami sandwiches.

The full guide, with the ones that didn't make it and why: The 10 Oldest Restaurants in New York City (Local’s Guide).