New York Dearest
The guide, $35

The Best of New York · Eat · Desserts

The best pumpkin pie in New York City

Updated September 2026. 10 places.

I have a soft spot for New York City, and its Pumpkin Pie scene is a big reason why. From hole-in-the-wall gems to neighborhood staples, these are my picks.

We cover pie shops and bakeries that offer slices and whole pies that can be ordered in advance for any fall celebration you may need. But enough talking, I know why you’re here. Let’s dive right into the best pumpkin pies in New York City!

Antonina PattizWriter and photographer · how I decide
Best of New York 2026, New York Dearest

Best pumpkin pie in New York City, 2026

  1. Balthazar BakeryBakery · SohoBut after trying the pie yourself, you’ll soon realize why it’s considered one of the best pumpkin pies in all of New York City.
  2. Lady MBakery · Upper East SideThe creamy flavor of pumpkin and fall spices work in unison with the soft graham cracker crust creating one of the best pumpkin pies New York City has ever seen tasted.
  3. Magnolia BakeryBakery · West VillageGood luck finding a list of bakeries serving the best pumpkin pie in NYC that doesn’t include the iconic Magnolia Bakery.
  4. Marthas Country BakingBakery · Multiple LocationsExpect to find thick, creamy pumpkin goodness baked into a golden-brown crust that’s just as thick as the pie.
  5. Milk BarBakery · Multiple LocationsAlthough on the thinner side, the dense pumpkin pie packs a flavorful punch.
  6. Petee’s Pie CompanyBakery · Lower East SideLet me tell you something a lot of other locals would agree with me on, Petee’s makes the best pumpkin pie in New York City, period.
  7. Bubby’sRestaurant · TribecaOwner Ron Silver describes eating here as the “day after Christmas” and it’s a fitting description.
  8. Four and Twenty BlackbirdsBakery · Park Slope, BrooklynThe end product is a rich, creamy, gem of a pumpkin pie that nearly tastes like cheesecake but is more subdued, with a hint of tanginess.
  9. Little Pie CompanyBakery · Hell's KitchenThe texture is smooth and spiced.
  10. Pie CorpsBakery · Greenpoint, BrooklynPie Corps is the kind of spot that makes living in NYC worth the rent.

On the map

Where they are

9 neighborhoods, Multiple Locations and Soho most of all.

Multiple Locations

Greenpoint, Brooklyn

Hell's Kitchen

Lower East Side

Park Slope, Brooklyn

Soho

Tribeca

Upper East Side

West Village

Best of New York 2026, New York Dearest

The Best of New York 2026

The seal

If you're on this list, this is yours.

Every place on this list is welcome to display the Best of New York 2026 seal. It's the same seal for every place on every Best list, it's free, and it can't be bought.

Sharing it is optional. There's no need to post about it, link back or tag anyone. If you do link, the code below points to the guide this list comes from, so readers see the recommendation in context.

The code. Paste it where the seal should sit.

<a href="https://newyorkdearest.com/best-pumpkin-pie-nyc/">
  <img src="https://newyorkdearest.com/assets/recognition/2026/best-of-new-york-2026.svg"
       alt="Best of New York 2026, New York Dearest"
       width="1800" height="1800" style="width:320px;max-width:100%;height:auto">
</a>

The files

Download PNGDownload SVGDownload the larger PNG

PNG: 1800 by 1800 pixels with transparent corners, for email and social. The larger PNG: 3600 by 3600 pixels. SVG: the vector, sharp at any size.

Is one of these yours? Get the seal for your place Request a window decal

The full guide, with the ones that didn't make it and why: 12 Spots For The Best Pumpkin Pie in New York City.