Shop · Shops · 2026
The best toy stores in New York.
Every one from my own visits, updated September 2026. 12 places.
A lot of families that visit New York City with kids take the time to pick out memorable souvenirs from the famous toy stores in NYC. A small toy is a great way to commemorate a fun trip to NYC! I’m pregnant with my first (so excited!) and have spent my fair share of time perusingHere’s a roundup of my personal favorites.
- American Girl PlaceStoreThe American Girl Place store in NYC is a dream destination for many young girls.
- Build-A-Bear WorkshopStore · MidtownBuild-A-Bear Workshops are popular throughout the country, but the children’s store in New York City is exceptional.
- CAMP StoreStore · FlatironIf your kid loves mystery and adventure then they’re going to love CAMP, the most creative toy store in New York City.
- FAO SchwarzStore · Midtown (Rockefeller Center)In operation since 1862, FAO Schwarz is officially the oldest toy store in America (and the most famous toy store in New York City).
- Grandma’s PlaceStore · Harlemthere’s no denying this one of the most special children’s stores in New York City.
- Greenpoint ToysStore · GreenpointThis iconic New York City toy store has been serving Brooklyn for more than 30 years.
- Kidding AroundStore · ChelseaWith a strong reputation for quality and value, Kidding Around has been recognized by New York Magazine as the Best Indie Toy Store in NYC.
- Lego Flagship StoreStore · Midtown
- Mary Arnold ToysStore · Upper East SideAsk any New Yorker about the most charming toy stores in New York City and someone will definitely mention Mary Arnold Toys in the Upper East Side.
- Mini JakeStore · WilliamsburgMini Jake is not your typical NYC toy store, not even close.
- Playing MantisStore · TribecaPlaying Mantis a distinctive destination for anyone seeking unique and environmentally conscious toys in NYC.
- Toy TokyoStore · East VillageMake no mistake, Toy Tokyo is the best toy store in New York City for action figures.
American Girl Place
Store
The American Girl Place store in NYC is a dream destination for many young girls.
Build-A-Bear Workshop
Store · Midtown · 22 W. 34th Street
Build-A-Bear Workshops are popular throughout the country, but the children’s store in New York City is exceptional.
CAMP Store
Store · Flatiron
If your kid loves mystery and adventure then they’re going to love CAMP, the most creative toy store in New York City.
FAO Schwarz
Store · Midtown (Rockefeller Center) · 30 Rockefeller Plaza, New York, NY
In operation since 1862, FAO Schwarz is officially the oldest toy store in America (and the most famous toy store in New York City).
Grandma’s Place
Store · Harlem · 84 W 120th St, New York, NY
there’s no denying this one of the most special children’s stores in New York City.
Greenpoint Toys
Store · Greenpoint · 738 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY
This iconic New York City toy store has been serving Brooklyn for more than 30 years.
Kidding Around
Store · Chelsea · 60 W 15th St, New York, NY
With a strong reputation for quality and value, Kidding Around has been recognized by New York Magazine as the Best Indie Toy Store in NYC.
Mary Arnold Toys
Store · Upper East Side · 1178 Lexington Ave, New York, NY
Ask any New Yorker about the most charming toy stores in New York City and someone will definitely mention Mary Arnold Toys in the Upper East Side.
Mini Jake
Store · Williamsburg · 178 N 9th St, Brooklyn, NY
Mini Jake is not your typical NYC toy store, not even close.
Playing Mantis
Store · Tribeca · 32 N Moore St, New York, NY
Playing Mantis a distinctive destination for anyone seeking unique and environmentally conscious toys in NYC.
Toy Tokyo
Store · East Village · 91 2nd Ave, New York, NY
Make no mistake, Toy Tokyo is the best toy store in New York City for action figures.
Best toy stores in New York, 2026
The seal
Every place on this list can show it. It links back here, so a reader sees the whole list and how it was made. No fee.
Is one of these yours?
The full guide, with the ones that didn't make it and why: 14 Charming New York City Toy Stores (Local’s List).