New York Dearest
The guide, $35
A restaurant · Midtown · on two New York Dearest lists

Don Antonio NYC

Worth it. Don Antonio makes legitimately excellent Neapolitan pizza eight blocks from Times Square.

Antonina Pattiz
Antonina PattizFrom my list Best places to eat near Times Square
Address
309 W 50th St Directions
Website
donantoniopizza.com

Everything I’ve written about Don Antonio NYC. It’s on two of my lists, Best places to eat near Times Square and Best gluten-free pizza in New York City. First, what to order and what to know.

  1. Best places to eat near Times SquareWorth it
  2. Best gluten-free pizza in New York CityWorth it

Before you go

What I order

The signature is the montanara, a fried pizza dough topped with smoked buffalo mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and basil. A margherita is about $22.

From Best places to eat near Times Square
Good to know

A word to the wise, Caporuscio’s pies are a hot commodity and Don Antonio’s doesn’t take reservations, so be prepared for a short wait.

From Best gluten-free pizza in New York City
Worth it. Been? Say if you agree.

Every list it’s on

Worth it

Reservations recommended, especially on show nights.

What I wrote thereFold it away

309 West 50th Street. Don Antonio makes legitimately excellent Neapolitan pizza eight blocks from Times Square. The signature is the montanara, a fried pizza dough topped with smoked buffalo mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and basil. A margherita is about $22.

This is a proper sit-down Italian restaurant with white tablecloths and good wine. It’s the kind of place where you can have a real meal without feeling like you’re at a tourist factory. Reservations recommended, especially on show nights.

Worth it

The food world of pizza has historically been run by men, but Don Antonio’s Giorgia Caporuscio is looking to change that.

What I wrote thereFold it away

The food world of pizza has historically been run by men, but Don Antonio’s Giorgia Caporuscio is looking to change that. Caporuscio has been dubbed the Queen of Neapolitan Pizza and it’s not hard to taste why.

The menu at Don Antonio’s is made up of 45 different pies and a handful of fried pizzas (popular in Naples). Every pizza on the menu can be made gluten-free, so you’ll have a ton of NYC gluten-free pizzas to choose from.

We recently did a taste test which included a gluten-free pizza (Truffle Burrata & Prosciutto), a fried pizza (the Montanara), and another of their signatures (Pistacchio & Salsciccia). Each one was the best and delicious in its own right but the most surprising of all was the gluten-free which could not be distinguished from the regular pies.

A word to the wise, Caporuscio’s pies are a hot commodity and Don Antonio’s doesn’t take reservations, so be prepared for a short wait.

Best of New York 2026, New York Dearest
On The Best of New York

I put Don Antonio NYC on two of my best lists

Get the digital sealRequest a window decal

Missing something?

Seen a closure, a price that moved or a better one next door?

Tell me. The answer lands on this page.

Tell me

The letter

One email a week when New York changes. A place closes, a date lands.

One a week at most. Unsubscribe in one click.