New York Dearest
The guide, $35
A place · Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · on 1 of my list

Little Pie Company.

Worth it, says Antonina. The texture is smooth and spiced.

Antonina Pattiz
Antonina PattizI went myself · from my Best pumpkin pie in New York
Where Little Pie Company appears on New York Dearest

It's on 1 of my list. Each entry below is what I wrote about it there, with my verdict on that list, the fullest first.

Best pumpkin pie in New York

No. 9 on that list8 min from the subway
Worth it
  • Subway1, 2, 3, 7, A, C, E, N, Q, R, S, W to Times Sq-42 St, 8 min
  • Address424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
  • From my guide, updated September 2026.

Offering a handful of large pies, mini pies, and slices. Little Pie Company takes great care of its customers and guarantees quality with every bite. All pies are made from scratch, in-house with the same care and attention to detail as you’d get at your grandmother’s house.

During the fall months, Little Pie Company rolls out their classic pumpkin pie and we can’t get enough. The texture is smooth and spiced. Ordering the mini pumpkin pie is always my preference because no one can force me to share!

For over 30 years the beloved pie shop has been creating loyal customers out of both locals and visitors alike. They show no plans of slowing down anytime soon. So if you’re searching for the best pumpkin pies in NYC, set your sights on Little Pie Company and don’t ever look back.

Read it on the list
Worth it, says Antonina. Been? Say if you agree.
Little Pie Company

Nearby, from my lists

Worth it, within a ten-minute walk
Missing something?

A closure, a price that moved, a better one next door.

Tell me and the desk checks it before anything changes here. When I answer, it lands on this page and in your inbox.

Tell me

The letter

One email a week when New York changes. A place closes, a date lands, I finally try somewhere. Written by me, not a robot.

One a week at most. Unsubscribe in one click.

Little Pie Company

Hell's Kitchen