New York Dearest
The guide, $35
A bar · Upper East Side · on four New York Dearest lists

The Penrose

Worth it. The delicious food and cozy rustic vibe create an ideal setting for a romantic date night.

Antonina Pattiz
Antonina PattizFrom my list Best bars on the Upper East Side
Address
1590 2nd Ave Directions
Subway
Q to 86 St, 4 min
Website
penrosebar.com

Before you go

What I order

Pair your meal with an expert breakfast cocktail (the Bloody Mary is excellent) and make the most of your visit.

From Best brunch on the Upper East Side
Good to know

As someone who’s spent their fair share of time in bars in this city, The Penrose is special. Stepping into The Penrose any time of day you can’t help but immediately recognize you’re in a top notch spot.

From Best happy hours on the Upper East Side
When to go

Come evening time, the Upper East Side restaurant transforms into one of the neighborhoods top bars, strictly 21+ after 8PM.

From Best restaurants on the Upper East Side
Worth it. Been? Say if you agree.

Every list it’s on

Worth it

Originally opened as an Irish pub with an emphasis on whisky, the Penrose has grown to include an impressive food menu outshined only by the cocktails on offer.

What I wrote thereFold it away

To the untrained eye, it’s hard to believe that a neighborhood bar could double as one of the best brunch restaurants on the Upper East Side, but here we are. Originally opened as an Irish pub with an emphasis on whisky, the Penrose has grown to include an impressive food menu outshined only by the cocktails on offer.

As far as brunch fare goes, the cinnamon french toast is an easy favorite. Made with brioche, vanilla cream cheese. If you’re the savory sort, the hot honey fried chicken sandwich is not to be missed.

Pair your meal with an expert breakfast cocktail (the Bloody Mary is excellent) and make the most of your visit.

Worth it

The UES happy hour special runs from 3 pm to 7 pm, offering $2 off beer, wine, and well drinks.

What I wrote thereFold it away

As someone who’s spent their fair share of time in bars in this city, The Penrose is special. Stepping into The Penrose any time of day you can’t help but immediately recognize you’re in a top notch spot. This bar checks all the right boxes – beautiful, vibey, and affordable.

If you don’t find room at the first bar near the entrance, head to the second dimly lit bar in the back.

Regarding happy hour, admittedly the price cuts alone wouldn’t quality The Penrose as one of the best happy hour deals on the Upper East Side, it’s still one of my favorites, given the overall experience. The UES happy hour special runs from 3 pm to 7 pm, offering $2 off beer, wine, and well drinks.

One of my personal favorites is their dirty-pickle martini.

Worth it

Not surprisingly to those who have been, The Penrose is one of the best bars in the Upper East Side.

What I wrote thereFold it away

Not surprisingly to those who have been, The Penrose is one of the best bars in the Upper East Side. The delicious food and cozy rustic vibe create an ideal setting for a romantic date night.

When you walk in you’ll notice a bar immediately to your left. If it’s full, keep walking to the back bar which is more dimly lit and sports an even swankier vibe.

For those visiting during regular bar hours, The Penrose stands out as one of the best cocktail bars on the Upper East Side, offering a diverse drink selection. The unique dirty-pickle martini is a noteworthy choice, showcasing the bar’s creativity and flavor profiles.

Worth it

Surprisingly budget-friendly for the UES, most dinner plates are under $20, offering ample portions, making The Penrose a place you need to try for foodies seeking the best dining experience on the Upper East Side.

What I wrote thereFold it away

The Penrose has a charming rustic vibe, creating the perfect setting for casual Sunday brunches with friends. Known for its classic American dishes, don’t overlook the irresistible French toast sticks. Come evening time, the Upper East Side restaurant transforms into one of the neighborhoods top bars, strictly 21+ after 8PM.

Surprisingly budget-friendly for the UES, most dinner plates are under $20, offering ample portions, making The Penrose a place you need to try for foodies seeking the best dining experience on the Upper East Side.

Missing something?

Seen a closure, a price that moved or a better one next door?

Tell me. The answer lands on this page.

Tell me

The letter

One email a week when New York changes. A place closes, a date lands.

One a week at most. Unsubscribe in one click.