What I wrote thereFold it away
205 East Houston Street, Lower East Side. Open since 1888. You’ve seen it in “When Harry Met Sally.” You’ve seen it on every food show ever filmed. And yes, the pastrami sandwich ($28) is worth the hype. It’s hand-carved, piled absurdly high on rye bread with spicy brown mustard, and it’s one of the most famous foods in America.
Here’s what you need to know before you go. When you walk in, they hand you a ticket. Do not lose this ticket. I’m serious. If you lose it, there’s a $50 charge. Take the ticket, get in the carving line (not the table-service side unless you want to pay more and wait longer), and order at the counter.
The cutter will give you a sample slice while they make your sandwich. This is when you tip. A dollar or two on the counter. The sample is partially a taste test and partially a social contract. Tip the cutter and you’ll notice your sandwich gets a little more generous. That’s just how Katz’s works.
Is $28 a lot for a sandwich? Yes. Is the sandwich big enough for two people to split? Also yes. Should you go at least once? Absolutely. Should you go every time you’re on the Lower East Side? That depends on how you feel about spending $28 on a sandwich, but I’m not going to judge you either way.
- Cost$28
- Address205 East Houston Street
- From my guide, published June 2026.


