The list, in my order
19 I’d go back to and 4 only if it suits you. My verdict on every one, and the ones nearby from my other lists.
Juliana's

In my opinion, the top three pizza spots in NYC are Juliana’s in DUMBO, Rubirosa in SoHo, and John’s Of Bleecker Street in the West Village.
Rubirosa
In my opinion, the top three pizza spots in NYC are Juliana’s in DUMBO, Rubirosa in SoHo, and John’s Of Bleecker Street in the West Village.
John's Of Bleecker Street
In my opinion, the top three pizza spots in NYC are Juliana’s in DUMBO, Rubirosa in SoHo, and John’s Of Bleecker Street in the West Village.
Eileen’s Special Cheesecake

Consider swinging by Eileen’s Special Cheesecake in SoHo (non-negotiable if you’re a fan of the famous NYC treat).
Russ & Daughters

You won’t find better lox in the city than at Russ & Daughters on the Lower East Side.
Ess-a-Bagel
For those who just want a classic bagel and schmear, Ess-a-Bagel never disappoints.
Nathan's Famous

Nothing beats a classic hotdog from Nathan’s, but if you like options, check out 10 Iconic NYC Hotdogs Everyone Needs to Try.
Katz's Deli

Katz’s Deli is pretty hard to beat, but a close competitor is 2nd Ave Deli in the Upper East Side.
2nd Ave Deli
Katz’s Deli is pretty hard to beat, but a close competitor is 2nd Ave Deli in the Upper East Side.
Pastrami Queen
Origin. The pastrami sandwich originated in Eastern Europe from Jewish communities. But it wasn’t until the late 1800s that this hearty NYC dish truly found its fame in the bustling streets of New York City. Made from highly seasoned smoked beef, pastrami was traditionally prepared by curing and smoking. In New York delicatessens, thinly sliced pastrami is typically served between slices of rye bread with mustard and pickles.
Today, the pastrami sandwich remains a beloved fixture of New York City’s food scene, renowned for robust flavor and hearty portions, it knows how to satisfy. As for the best deli in town? That title goes to Katz in the Lower East Side.
Serving folks with one of the most famous foods in NYC since 1888, Katz’s is officially the oldest deli in the country. The iconic cafeteria-style deli is adorned with celebrity photos. And nothing keeps folks coming back more than its famous mile-high thick-cut pastrami on rye. With charred outer layers, generous seasonings, and a texture that melts in your mouth, this stuff is irresistible and well worth the wait.
Where to eat it. Katz’s Deli is pretty hard to beat, but a close competitor is 2nd Ave Deli in the Upper East Side. Another great spot to try the iconic NYC food is Pastrami Queen (three locations in the city).
Unpopular opinion. I’ll say it. New York-Style Pizza deserves way more recognition than it gets.
Third Ave Ale House
My top picks are Third Ave Ale House and Loreley Beer Garden.
Loreley Beer Garden

My top picks are Third Ave Ale House and Loreley Beer Garden.
Bread's Bakery

Bread’s Bakery on the Upper East Side (this famous NYC treat is exclusive to this location), hands down offers one of the most memorable black and white cookies in the city.
Halal Guys
- Cost$
- From my guide, updated September 2026.
Origin. Halal Guys, an iconic street food cart, originated in New York City in the early 1990s. It began as a humble food cart operated by three Egyptian immigrants near the corner of 53rd Street and 6th Avenue in Manhattan. Their savory halal meats served over rice with signature white sauce quickly gained popularity among New Yorkers, leading to the expansion of their food cart operation and the eventual opening of brick-and-mortar restaurants across NYC and beyond.
The Halal Guys have stands everywhere. This popular NYC food cart is never too far, no matter where you are in the city. Offering straightforward yet tasty options like gyros or platters with rice, chicken or beef, lettuce, and tomato, they adhere to Halal dietary guidelines. A quintessential cheap eat in the city, I can’t envision NYC without them.
Where to eat it. Expect to find multiple locations scattered throughout the Big Apple when searching for this famous New York City dish. The best part? Many locations stay open until midnight. Some spots even run until 4 AM, making it one of the most iconic late-night food spots in NYC.
Breads Bakery

While Bread’s Bakery is tough top, there are plenty of other fantastic places in the city to enjoy this iconic NYC food.
Oneg Bakery
Established favorites like Oneg Bakery in Williamsburg offer superb options.
Michaeli Bakery
Hidden gems like Michaeli Bakery in the Lower East Side also deliver great flavor.
Grand Central Oyster Bar
The chowder has a slight kick to it and is extremely satisfying.
Dominique Ansel Bakery

Dominique Ansel Bakery in SoHo is where this iconic NYC treat was created.
Balthazar
In my opinion, the ultimate eggs Benedict can be found at Balthazar’s in SoHo, especially the smoked salmon version.
Sarabeth's

Another dependable spot for this iconic NYC dish is Sarabeth’s.
Magnolia Bakery

Origin. Founded in 1996 in the West Village, Magnolia Bakery’s claim to fame comes from the iconic banana pudding. The famous NYC food features layers of creamy pudding, fresh bananas, and vanilla wafers. It’s quickly become a customer favorite thanks to its rich flavor and nostalgic appeal.
Magnolia’s serves all your sweet treat needs including irresistibly moist cakes and divine cheesecakes. But the banana pudding remains a. It represents the bakery’s dedication to timeless American desserts with a modern twist.
Where to eat it. Magnolia Bakery has multiple locations in the city. But nothing beats the flagship store. It was featured in the TV show Sex and the City. It was an episode where Carrie and Miranda shared a cupcake while gushing over Carrie’s new crush (season 3, episode 5).
Shanghai 21
You’ll be hard-pressed to find a better General Tso’s Chicken than in Chinatown, specifically Shanghai 21.
