Best Thanksgiving dinner restaurants in New York, 2026.

The Plaza Hotel has been a fan-favorite for an step up Thanksgiving dinner in NYC for more than 100 years (here’s the Thanksgiving menu. Served in 1899). The luxury hotel’s elegance is second to none, so if you’re looking for a place to splurge, the Plaza gets my vote. The menu and pricing for 2024 hasn’t been announced, but in years past it’s been north of $200.

The traditional Thanksgiving dinner menu is a simple affair. Oven roasted turkey is joined by incredible sides like cornbread, mashed potatoes and tart cranberry sauce.

A New York City gem, Anton’s oozes charm impossible to resist. Last year the traditional NYC Thanksgiving dinner menu was a three course, prix-fixe menu that featured roasted Turkey and classic sides (and a kids menu with chicken tenders). It’s safe to assume the 2024 menu will be similar.

Although the restaurant has yet to post their 2024 NYC Thanksgiving dinner menu, in 2023 it clocked in at $115 per person.

My adviceCome during off-peak hours if you can. The food is just as good, the service is more relaxed, and you might actually get a seat without waiting.

Anyone who’s been to Rudy’s might be surprised to learn the bar serves one of the best Thanksgiving feasts in NYC. The joint is famous for cheap beer and hot-dogs (and a pig statue named Baron Von Swine). But don’t worry, you won’t need to sacrifice franks for turkey.

During Thanksgiving all the traditional fixings are on offer. Better still, in a tremendous show of generosity, Rudy’s serves a free Thanksgiving dinner in New York City for those who can’t make it home for the holidays. Faith in humanity.restored. The feast starts at 1pm and goes until food runs out (and it will run out).

A staple in New York City’s brunch scene, Jacob’s Pickle makes a mouthwatering Thanksgiving dinner. The southern restaurant swaps fried chicken and waffles for mashed potatoes and turkey, all prepared with the same excellence locals have come to rely on over the years.

The restaurant’s famous mac & cheese gives them a leg up on our list of the best Thanksgiving Dinner in NYC. As an added bonus, the location the Upper West Side makes it an easy destination after the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade.

Unpopular opinion. I’ll die on this hill, you haven’t really experienced NYC food culture until you’ve tried The Plaza Hotel.

Tavern On The Green is one of the most iconic restaurants in New York City. Cozy and decorated for the holidays. It’s also one of the first restaurants to open Thanksgiving dinner reservations, and they go fast. Prices in 2023 started at $135 per person with a mandatory 20% gratuity.

Frank Prisinzano is the celebrated chef behind Lil Frankie’s, Frank, Supper and Daddies. Incredibly, Prisinzano has made a tradition of hosting anyone celebrating Thanksgiving in NYC alone by offering a free four-course dinner at all of his restaurants, no questions asked.

Things like this make me love this city, because with 8.5 million residents there no reason to have Thanksgiving dinner in NYC alone. The only request is that you tip the staff.

What do Teddy Roosevelt, Albert Einstein and Babe Ruth have in common? They’ve all enjoyed a meal at one of the most iconic restaurants in New York City, Keen’s Steakhouse. Contrary to what the name suggests, Keen’s is best known for mutton chops, and during Thanksgiving dinner the NYC restaurant offers even more variety.

In addition to the famous mutton chops you’ll also get to choose between turkey, prime rib, filet mignon and dover sole. In 2023, Keen’s four-course Thanksgiving dinner was priced at $149 per person.

Fraunces Tavern has been in operation since 1762, effectively making this one of the oldest (but not the oldest) bars in New York City. The iconic watering hole holds historical significance that can’t be beat, even hosting George Washington several occasions.

Needless to say, Fraunces Tavern is the ideal Thanksgiving dinner restaurant in NYC for history buffs. In 2023 dinner consisted of three courses that ran $95 per person. The main courses included traditional turkey, filet mignon, pan seared branzino and pesto pappardelle.

Rosemary’s has its own rooftop vegetable garden that helps guide the menu, a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality. Warm and inviting, the Italian restaurant offers a traditional Thanksgiving dinner for the night.

Carmine’s is a New York City mainstay that has been around for more than three decades. Catering to family style dining, it’s a perfect Thanksgiving dinner restaurant in NYC. In fact, their Thanksgiving dinner feast is meant for groups of 6-8 people, and can be enjoyed as take-out or dine-in experience.

Turkey, Brussel sprouts, mashed potatoes and gravy cover the table making it hard to know where to start. Plus, since the flagship location is located centrally in Times Square I’d recommend planning to watch a Broadway show afterwards because you’ll be too stuffed to walk.

Famous for dishing out some of the best soul food on the East Coast, Jacob Restaurant is worth a detour, especially on Thanksgiving. The reason? This Harlem mainstay has been serving free Thanksgiving dinner in NYC for 14 years.

The wait at Jacob Restaurant can get pretty long on Thanksgiving, why not take the time to chat with some of the other folks in line? At the end of the day Thanksgiving is a holiday meant to bring us together. Or, place your catering order ahead of time and enjoy it at home with friends & family.

You know the way a dog’s ears perk up when they see a squirrel? Well mine do that when someone. Seriously, this joint is famous for their pancakes but craft a mouthwatering Thanksgiving dinner in NYC. The potatoes, biscuits and pies are all year-round dishes Bubby’s makes perfectly, and on Thanksgiving they team up with turkey or ham for a home-run.

In 2023 Bubby’s prix-fixe Thanksgiving dinner ran $125 per person, reservations were required and each reservation was for an hour and a half.

Serving a tons of traditional American fare, The Smith is a hot-spot for locals and tourists alike and one of the best restaurants for Thanksgiving dinner in New York City. Crowds are all but guaranteed but with so many locations sprinkled around New York City the restaurant shouldn’t be too hard to get a reservation at.

The restaurant has four locations across New York City. One in the Upper West Side (perfect for a post-Macy’s Day Parade meal), another in Nomad, one in the East Village and the last one in Midtown. In 2022 The Smith charged $78 per person for a three course, Thanksgiving Dinner, and the NYC restaurant will likely charge a similar price tag in 2024.

Craft is a former Michelin star restaurant that exudes a level of sophistication that’s hard to beat. If you’re in need of a NYC Thanksgiving dinner restaurant to impress a special someone or treat your out of town guests, Craft will is sure to dazzle.

The seasonal, farm-to-table American fare will leave you stuffed and you’re going to be counting down the days until Thanksgiving rolls around the next year. 2024 menu and pricing is not yet available, but I will update this post as soon as I have more information.