The list, in my order
15 I’d go back to and 1 only if it suits you. My verdict on every one, and the ones nearby from my other lists.
Balthazars

- Address80 Spring St, New York, NY 10012
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
For an iconic New Year’s Day dining experience in NYC, consider Balthazar’s. The Parisian brasserie boasts a romantic ambiance with garlands, twinkling lights, warm tones, and red-leather booths, a scene straight out of a movie. Since its opening in 1997 by Keith McNally, the food has been exceptional. Don’t miss the outstanding eggs Benedict with smoked salmon or the delectable French onion soup. If brunch is booked, try their bakery next door for the best chocolate donuts and a must-try chai latte.
La Grande Boucherie

- Address145 W 53rd St, New York, NY 10019
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
La Grande Boucherie is a French restaurant that feels more like an elegant museum. The romantic interior could make anyone fall in love and the food is delicious. I’ve been to La Grande Boucherie more times than I’d like to admit, but I am a sucker for the brunch –especially the Eggs Norwegian (eggs Benedict with smoked salmon). The eggs are poached to perfection and the hollandaise sauce is full of flavor.
This is one of the more popular restaurants open on New Years Day in NYC, so make sure to plan ahead. If you can’t get a reservation for the morning, don’t worry, the dinner menu is just as good! Start the new year on the right foot and treat yourself to a nice steak dinner at one of the best restaurants open on New Years Day in NYC.
Rosemary’s

- Address18 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
Dedicated to the owner’s mother, Rosemary, this restaurant strives to capture the love found in home-cooked meals. With its rooftop vegetable garden supplying fresh produce, Rosemary’s is a personal favorite for New Year’s Day dining in NYC.
The kind staff, lingering Christmas decorations, and charming ambiance, enhanced by wreaths and ceiling lights, make it a standout. The cocktail menu, featuring the impressive Garden Martini, offers unmistakable freshness. Need suggestions on what to order? I highly recommend the rigatoni and bolognese, both wonderfully fresh and creamy.
Kyma

I stumbled upon Kyma accidentally one day while exploring the Flatiron District and I am so lucky I was hungry that day because wow! The restaurant serves a lot of fresh fish (which I later found out is flown in daily from the Mediterranean!) and Greek food like Spanakopita (flakey phyllo dough with spinach and cheese).
The interior was clean and bright and the staff was quick and attentive. It wasn’t until I got home (and couldn’t stop thinking about my meal) that I did a little research and discovered Kyma was a Michelin star rated restaurant. Everything made sense at that point and I quickly realized this was one of the best restaurants open on New Years day in NYC.
Serra By Birreria

- Address200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
Serra By Birreria is located on the rooftop of Eataly in the Flatiron District, and it’s Italian name roughly translates to greenhouse brewery. The seasonal restaurant serves delicious Italian food and (very) well crafted cocktails. With every changing season, the restaurant manages to outdo the previous decor.
In the winter Serra by Birreria transforms into Serra Alpina, meant to make guests feel like they’re in a cabin in the Italian mountains. The snow dusted branches that blanket the ceiling make this one of the most charming restaurants open on New Years day in NYC. Even though it’s on a rooftop the restaurant is enclosed and well heated, keeping it as cozy as can be.
Bills Bar & Burger

- Address85 West St, New York, NY 10006 & 16 West 51st St, New York, NY 10019
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
For a relaxed New Year’s Day meal in NYC, check out Bill’s Bar & Burger. This sports bar specializes in delicious comfort food, with standout burgers and shakes. With over ten burger options, including classics like The Bill’s and inventive ones like The Big Mamooo topped with mac & cheese and BBQ brisket, there’s something for everyone.
If you’re feeding a group, try the Killer B’s burger tower, featuring five mini burgers with various toppings. Bill’s Bar & Burger stands out as one of the few spots open late until 11:00 PM on New Year’s Day in NYC.
Fun Fact: The Rockefeller Center location is the biggest standalone burger joint in the country.
Cafe D’Alsace
- Address1703 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
Cafe d’Alsace, rooted in the Alsace region of France, blends both German and French influences due to the area’s historical ties to both nations. With third-generation chef Philippe Roussel’s culinary expertise, the restaurant offers a delightful fusion.
Zou Zou’s

- Address385 9th Ave Suite 85, New York, NY 10001
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
Discover a new restaurant open on New Year’s Day in NYC at Hudson Yards, a distinctive Mediterranean spot that stands out in the city’s culinary scene. While the entrees are excellent, Zou Zou’s truly shines with mind-blowing appetizers. The whipped ricotta with Saffron Apricots is a standout, and the Hot Kasseri Cheese and focaccia are a spectacle, the cheese arrives in a skillet and is lit on fire right before your eyes! Beyond the captivating experience, the food at Zou Zou’s is unforgettable, leaving you with a lasting craving.
Five Napkin Burger
- Address2315 Broadway, New York, NY 10024 & 630 9th Ave. New York, NY 10036
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
For a quick and satisfying bite on New Year’s Day in NYC, head to Five Napkin Burger. After a night of celebration, the last thing you want is to cook when you wake up. Luckily, NYC offers plenty of spots for great food, and rumor has it, greasy food helps with hangovers.
Five Napkin Burger is my preferred choice after a night out. The appetizers are fantastic, and the portions are ideal for sharing. True to its name, the burgers are juicy and bursting with flavor, necessitating the need for napkins to stay clean.
I recommend trying the 5 Napkin burger and the truffle burger, both are divine. It’s also one of the rare restaurants open on New Year’s Day in NYC that provides vegetarian options in a menu predominantly centered around meat.
The Smith

Serving a plethora of traditional American fare, The Smith is a hot-spot for locals and tourists alike and one of the best restaurants open on New Years day in NYC. Expect to find all the classics like omelettes, burgers, steaks, etc. Crowds are all but guaranteed at this popular restaurant but with so many locations sprinkled around New York City, you shouldn’t struggle making reservations. Of all the meals I had at The Smith, I find myself coming back, time and time again for the brunch. The cocktails are refreshing and the buttermilk pancakes are a clear stand-out.
Carmine’s
- Address200 West 44th Street & 2450 Broadway
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
If you have a lot of mouths to feed, I suggest making reservations at Carmine’s, one of the best restaurants open on New Years Day in NYC. The restaurant serves all the typical Italian fared food, from pasta to Tiramisu. But what truly sets them apart is the portion sizes.
Carmine’s doesn’t play around when it comes to family style dining, so this is one of those “don’t let your eyes be bigger than your stomach” situations. The reason? Your meal is intended to feel like an Italian wedding’s feast. The place is usually busy (which is a good sign) and the service is great. Oh! And don’t even think about skipping out on the the crispy garlic bread, you must order it!
Becco
- Cost$30 for unlimited pasta
- Address355 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
Located on restaurant row (a block with more than a century of culinary history near Times Square) Becco is an Italian restaurant that has changed the pasta game in NYC. To start things off, each table begins the meal with a complimentary bread basket and hey, anyone who offers free bread earns some brownie points in my book.
But what really sets Becco apart is that everyday, Executive Chef William Gallagher, creates what they call the Three Daily Pasta Preparations. Essentially, it’s a pasta special where customers are served table-side all three dishes, unlimitedly for $30! The price is hard to beat and this is a great restaurant open on New Years Day in NYC for a date night (or if you’re just craving unlimited pasta).
Quality Meats

- Address57 W 58th St, New York, NY 10019
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
The reason I feel confident adding Quality Meats to our list of restaurants open on New Years day in NYC is because of the extraordinary service. You leave the restaurant feeling like not only was the food great, but the employees actually cared that you had a good experience.
As the name suggests, Quality Meats serves, well… quality meat! Everything I’ve tasted at Quality Meats has been perfectly tender and juicy, practically melting in my mouth. The flavors are top-notch and I can’t recommend the Tomahawk ribeye enough.
Olio e Più
- Address3 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
One of the best restaurants open on New Years day in NYC is tucked away in the charming West Village. Famous for the Spaghetti Carbonara which is creamy, light and served with an egg yolk that blends beautifully with the pasta, Olio e Più serves some of the best Italian food in New York City.
The place is decorated in a way that makes you feel like you’ve stepped foot into a true Italian restaurant. And the food they serve is just as dreamy. The pizza is great but the pasta is where Olio e Più really stands out. Also the bruschetta ricotta is non-negotiable, you have to order it!
Quality Bistro

- Address120 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
For anyone looking for a great steak and delicious appetizers, I can’t say enough good things about Quality Bistro. Luckily for us, Quality Bistro is one of the best restaurants open on New Years day in NYC. The interior of the restaurant is insane and the low-lighting adds a romantic feel to the space.
You can’t go wrong ordering anything off the menu, but if you need some guidance I hope to help. To say I suggest ordering the French onion soup or tuna tartar to start, would be an understatement. It’s not a want, but a need! That paired with the steak and frites and any of the delectable desserts , you are in for quite the night. This is a perfect spot for a date night or catching up with some friends. Just make sure to hurry and make reservations since it’s one of the more popular restaurants open on New Years day in NYC.
Carnegie Diner & Cafe
- Address205 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
- From my guide, updated February 2024.
One of the best restaurants open on New Years Day in NYC is Carnegie Diner & Cafe because it was a spot created for the people. The atmosphere is cozy and feels home-y and the red booths add to the old school diner charm. The restaurant is the kind of place where there is food for all different kinds of hunger and needs. The menu is extensive and while all the dishes are tasty, I personally think Carnegie Diner & Cafe has perfected breakfast plates. Start the new year off with a big ol’ plate of pancakes or French toast and wash it down with some hot chocolate. You can always start that new diet on Monday! 😉
