It's on 3 of my lists. Each entry below is what I wrote about it there, with my verdict on that list, the fullest first.
- Address440 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
- From my guide, updated September 2026.
Dating back to 1916, Orwashers recently branched out with a second bakery in the Upper West Side. Serving New Yorkers for nearly 110 years, the bakery prides itself on using traditional baking methods that have been meticulously perfected over decades.
I suggest showing up early for the best selection because the most popular items sell out quickly. The croissants are delicious and the. Try to visit before noon for the freshest selection (just keeping it real, I’ve been burned a few times with stale pastries).
My adviceIf it’s your first time visiting, don’t sleep on the sticky-bun babka, jelly donuts and black-and-white cookies.
Established in 1916, Orwashers has remained a beloved institution in New York City, serving generations of locals. Renowned for their commitment to traditional baking techniques honed over a century, the Orwasher family brought their recipes from Hungary to the Upper East Side.
With their expertise in baking, it’s no surprise that Orwashers crafts some of the best black and white cookies in NYC. Blurring the line between cake and cookie, these treats have a fluffy, pancake-like texture. The frosting perfectly complements the cookie’s soft texture, offering a treat that melts in your mouth.
While many come for the bagels, seasoned locals recognize the hand-filled jelly donuts as hidden gems, among the best in NYC.